The World Bank has apologized for photographs on the web site for participants at its recent annual meetings, which showed offensive stereotypes about Ghana. A Ghanaian journalist broke the story after he saw the images portraying “a country full of hungry and miserable people.” This has prompted an outcry and debate in Ghana.
About Aid Watch
The Aid Watch blog is a project of New York University's Development Research Institute (DRI). This blog is principally written by William Easterly, author of "The Elusive Quest for Growth: Economists' Adventures and Misadventures in the Tropics" and "The White Man's Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good," and Professor of Economics at NYU. It is co-written by Laura Freschi and by occasional guest bloggers. Our work is based on the idea that more aid will reach the poor the more people are watching aid.
"Conscience is the inner voice that warns us somebody may be looking." - H.L. Mencken
Recent Comments
- Rukmini on Aid Watch blog ends; New work on development begins : This has been a valuable resource for me and I’m sorry to see it...
- Jesse on From Hell to Prosperity: I would like to see this graph with a comparative one which shows the number of people in each religion...
- Ellie on Aid Watch blog ends; New work on development begins : Sad to see you go, but I certainly respect the decision. Hope it is...
- Vivek Nemana on From Hell to Prosperity: Jeff, Well, the billionaire effect might explain a disproportionately high mean income, but...
- M on Aid Watch blog ends; New work on development begins : I agree that Bill and Laura should think about how they can get their message...
- Mr. Econotarian on Are Lax US Gun Laws Spilling Violence into Mexico? : The paper says: “DHS data gives the number of illegal...
Archives
Bill Easterly tweets
- RT @tkb: @meighanstone @bill_easterly @viewfromthecave Thanks from @worldbankdata team! http://t.co/aD4zp3Px & http://t.co/6APTLA7D ... about 6 hours ago from Twittelator ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @meighanstone: @bill_easterly @WorldBank @viewfromthecave you should be singing praises of @tkb and his team then (upstart World Bank ... about 6 hours ago from Twittelator ReplyRetweetFavorite
- Praise the @WorldBank! (for data visualization) http://t.co/ri7CvwdZ HT @viewfromthecave about 6 hours ago from Twittelator ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @lustrefound: New idea for Sandel: Writers as public intellectuals replaced by economists. RIP Carlos Fuentes. http://t.co/Zkpq1Shj h ... about 9 hours ago from Twittelator ReplyRetweetFavorite
Aid Watch tweets
- RT @viewfromthecave Healthy Dose top story: UNDP to Africa, End Hunger to Ensure Growth http://t.co/6b1tghMg about 8 hours ago from web ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @bill_easterly Leonardo DiCaprio's coffee has a remarkable effect on development. We're just a bit fuzzy on how. http://t.co/ITkKtwVG 08:08:48 PM May 15, 2012 from TweetDeck ReplyRetweetFavorite
- RT @NatalieNYT Study points to the complexities of giving & measuring the impact of charity http://t.co/zjZCCxth 06:25:03 PM May 15, 2012 from TweetDeck ReplyRetweetFavorite
- “Poverty: The audacity of hope” @TheEconomist describes an RCT by Esther Duflo http://t.co/ahFAljgc 05:23:35 PM May 15, 2012 from web ReplyRetweetFavorite





5 Comments
I’ve been following the back-and-forth on this here in Accra (albeit online). One of the original stories is at:
http://news.peacefmonline.com/social/201010/94202.php?storyid=100&#commentsread
Fun to read the comments to that piece too. A few, in fact, ponder whether a lawsuit is in order considering the displays of naked kids.
Reminded me of Aidwatch’s satirical post about a child suing an NGO for using his image on a brochure without permission/compensation.
This was bad, but then I was amazed that te images were the only spectacular thing he could report on. If you live in Ghana, you’d understand that there is a rush by lesser known Journalists to look for sensational stories. I think a private letter to the bank, protesting would have been effective too. But thats my opinion..
@ Franklin, I think the reporter managed to get attention of the media by reporting the story, which led to the public outcry and an apology from the country director in Ghana, no? I don’t know if a private letter would have been that effective.
Kudos to the reporter. I certainly agree there is a double standard. There should always be written consent for all photos displayed publicly.
I struggle sometimes with other types of portrayals that are more borderline. Is a picture of a women breastfeeding her child offensive to display? This is a pretty normal occurrence in many places and there would be little objection to a picture of it. Yet, if a similar picture of an American woman breastfeeding was publically displayed, it would be considered offensive (or tasteless, at a minimum). No? So, does the display of the photograph in the U.S. and/or the national background of the person in the photo matter? Is it offensive if displayed in the US, but not some parts of West Africa? Is it relative to the audience or the subject? I’d be interested to hear other people’s thoughts on this.
Where’s the Beef? Ghana is poor! WB figures 2009 real per capita GDP at $655. They joined the HIPC. People do take baths from buckets. At least the kid had soap and a source for water. Did everyone celebrate International Wash Your Hands With Soap Day Oct 15th? Id like to see what other pictures were so objectionable. Ghana is making good income from the new higher prices for gold and may well make a bundle from oil one day. In the mean time it is good to see that sensational journalism is alive and well and that the WB has not lost its sense of urgency to CYA when called NOT PC.
2 Trackbacks
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by William Easterly, Eric Yamoah, Conduit Journal, Stanléy M., One World Centre and others. One World Centre said: RT @bill_easterly: World Bank busted for stereotypical images of Ghana http://bit.ly/a9mm4o [...]
[...] a link for Aid Watch, I read this article with interest: The World Bank has apologized for displaying damning images of [...]