READER EXAM EDITION: come up with a coherent story in which this headline would (or will in the future) make sense.
About Aid Watch
The Aid Watch blog is a project of New York University's Development Research Institute (DRI). This blog is principally written by William Easterly, author of "The Elusive Quest for Growth: Economists Adventures and Misadventures in the Tropics" and "The White Man's Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good," and Professor of Economics at NYU. It is co-written by Laura Freschi and by occasional guest bloggers. Our work is based on the idea that more aid will reach the poor the more people are watching aid.
“Conscience is the inner voice that warns us somebody may be looking.” - H.L. Mencken
-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
- Ehui on African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? : About the pedophiles , I am not sure whether the Ghana Tourist...
- Sam Gardner on African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? : Of course, every income counts for a developing country,...
- Henning on African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? : Bill, what do you think about poverty being part of the...
- Andrew on African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? : I think the big problem with Mole is the lack of big cats. If...
- Word_Bandit on When financial crises are devastating to a country’s long-run prospects: Interesting. Though using the nomenclature...
- Conor Godfrey on African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? : Dear group, I am curious what you think of marketing...
Archives
Bill Easterly tweets
- When financial crises ARE devastating to a country's long run prospects (Q&A with Carmen Reinhart) http://bit.ly/a55V1d about 7 hours ago from bitly
- African tourism great potential vs. white elephant? This time the comments are better than the original post. http://bit.ly/cRc8l4 about 8 hours ago from bitly
- @BloomsburyUSA yes 08:15:26 PM July 28, 2010 from Twittelatorin reply to BloomsburyUSA
- African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? http://bit.ly/cRc8l4 05:47:56 PM July 28, 2010 from bitly
Aid Watch tweets
- Today's post: When financial crises ARE devastating to a country's long run prospects (Q&A with Carmen Reinhart) http://bit.ly/a55V1d about 3 hours ago from web
- RT @intldogooder Have been pulling together links on existing aid reform efforts here: http://www.how-matters.org/links-resources/ about 3 hours ago from web
- Today's post: African Tourism projects: great potential or white elephants? http://bit.ly/cRc8l4 06:24:49 PM July 28, 2010 from web
- Today's post: The Lives of Others http://bit.ly/9YDM6w 07:53:51 PM July 25, 2010 from web



3 Comments
Haitians save USA’s AAA bond rating
A report released today makes the case that Haitians who are based in the USA are responsible for the country’s high savings rate, high consumption rate and sudden reversal in the budget deficit. After US$100 billion billion in US Aid was spent on building the world’s deepest well and the world’s largest classroom on the earthquake-struck island, it is claimed that several billion dollars returned to the US.
Utilising remittance channels created for financial flows in the opposite direction – from the US to Haiti – Haitians living on the island felt that they should support their American-based counterparts now that they had a very deep well and a very, very large – albeit teacherless – classroom.
One Haitian man, who works for a INGO called Save Haitians In Texas, commented that “we have development now, but in the US they still get water from the taps and have only small classrooms. They helped us before, now its our turn to help them.”
However much of the money sent to the US appears to end up in the hands of those Haitians who claim high consultancy fees or who spend the cash on conference rooms, with such venues accounting for 12% of US GDP growth this year. White land cruisers and report publishing accounted fro 4% and 7% respectively.
Responding to criticism that Haitian aid to the US does not meet its beneficiaries, the Haitians Mobilisation Momentum Movement (Hmmm), an umbrella organisation, stated that ” We have just held a conference on this very matter, and we concluded that why give them fish when we can teach them to fish? Know what I mean? This is capacity building. Americans need to learn how to build big schools and deep wells.”
In separate developments, Chinese ministers today announced their intentions to buy New York and Washington, raising hopes for further stabilisation of the budget. The cities would be renamed Old World and Hasbeen.
1) The US is in a prime position to rebuild Haiti, which may be a profitable venture with the billions of dollars in aid from other countries. US contractors and construction firms get big deals in Haiti which expand the US tax base and hopefully helps get us out of the recession. Sure we’d like Haitians to rebuild the country and reap the full benefits of the aid, but if it turns into a political opportunity to create jobs then I doubt our government will pass it up. Maybe it even becomes a part of a job bill?
2) We allow young Haitians to immigrate to the US with some of the aid money. They’ll spend lots of the aid money as they get settled, benefiting Americans and expanding the tax base. They’ll also work and contribute to Social Security and Medicare without claiming many benefits from US social programs (aid orgs will likely provide such programs to Haiti victims so the US gov’t won’t have to). Effectively, we spend the aid money in the US while altering our demographics to keep our big entitlement programs solvent.
Between 2010 and 2014, Americans watched the demise of Haiti’s governmental structures, but at the same time witnessed the resilience of the Haitian people. This “laboratory” of social evolution forged a new understanding of how that process takes place, what the strengths of a society are at each stage, and how a better understanding of this process helps ALL countries improve themselves.
Despite sporadic violence and criminality immediately following the January 2010 earthquake, the Haitian people relied on the traditions of their culture and created new lives for themselves. Their resilience in the face of catastrophe challenged notions in the industrialized world that people in poor countries are “lazy” or “stupid.” The extended presence of these capable and resilient Haitians on web pages, Twitter tweets, and news networks invited Americans to see the disaster situation from the Haitian point of view.
As a result, starting in 2015, aid efforts shifted their focus from imposing American institutions for governance and business to working with individual Haitian communities to help them move up Maslow’s pyramid one need at a time. While this shift suggested that a much longer process would be required, progress could be seen at a community level over much shorter periods.
With its success working with Haiti and the understanding that Americans themselves gained in the process, by 2018 the U.S. had made explicit what had always been an undercurrent in American values – the desire to achieve social justice and equity throughout the world. These values had emerged in other prominent places during the 2010’s – namely the U.S. healthcare reform debate and efforts to tackle climate change and alleviate global poverty.
Working with financial institutions and other industrialized countries, in 2020 the U.S. redefined “creditworthiness” to include a commitment to global equity, sustainability, and social justice. The thinking was, how can someone be “creditworthy” if they are willing to tolerate violence, social injustice, or environmental degradation on a massive scale?
Given its success in Haiti and its commitment to achieving greater successes in the future, the U.S. is seen as a worthy member of the international community and given a AAA rating. While the rating overlooks some of the fiscal challenges that the U.S. continues to face, it is widely felt that it captures the factors that are most crucial to long-term success.
One Trackback
[...] readers of his blog to come up with ways in which the following headline might one day be true: Haitians save USA’s AAA bond rating. The question was in part a hint toward Easterly’s suggestion that letting in more Haitian [...]